BEST PAIRED WITH A TENACIOUS SPIRIT

Hands pouring whiskey from a bottle into a jigger, with a glass and lemons on a bar, featuring Monongahela Mash Straight Rye American Whisky Old Overholt.
  • Classic-Style

The Perfect Manhattan

A perfect balance of Overholt’s bold character with the elegance of vermouth. Stirred slow and served straight up — the kind of drink that lets the whiskey speak, with a whisper of bitters and citrus.

  • Easy
  • 3-5 min
  • Spirit-forward
Perfect Manhattan cocktail with a lemon twist, next to Monongahela Mash Straight Rye American Whisky Old Overholt.
Perfect Manhattan cocktail with a lemon twist, next to Monongahela Mash Straight Rye American Whisky Old Overholt.
  • Classic-Style

The Scofflaw

Overholt’s bold spice cuts through bright citrus and grenadine in this Prohibition-era classic. A cocktail with history — as spirited as the rye itself.

  • Easy
  • 3-5 min
  • Sour
Scofflaw cocktail being strained into a glass, with Monongahela Mash Straight Rye American Whisky Old Overholt.
Scofflaw cocktail being strained into a glass, with Monongahela Mash Straight Rye American Whisky Old Overholt.
  • Classic-Style

Whiksy Neat

Overholt Rye served neat — no distractions, no pretense. For those who appreciate whiskey in its purest form.

  • Easy
  • 3-5 min
  • Spirit-forward
Whiskey Neat being poured into a glass, next to Monongahela Mash Straight Rye American Whisky Old Overholt.
Whiskey Neat being poured into a glass, next to Monongahela Mash Straight Rye American Whisky Old Overholt.
  • Classic-Style

Old One Cold One

Old Overholt Rye with a cold beer on the side. A timeless pairing — straightforward, unpretentious, and built for those who like to keep it simple.

  • Easy
  • 3-5 min
  • Spirit-forward
Old one cold one cocktal with hand holding a glass of whiskey next to a bottle of American Whisky Old Overholt.
Old one cold one cocktal with hand holding a glass of whiskey next to a bottle of American Whisky Old Overholt.

FIND OUR SPIRIT

Discover our range of Key Straight American Rye Whisky.

Bottle and drink of American Whisky Old Overholt
MORE TO EXPLORE

OUR PRODUCTS

Crafting the next chapter of American Rye Whiskey

LEARN MORE
Whiskey bottle and two glasses on a table of American Rye Whiskly Monongahela Mash Old Overholt

OUR STORY

The Longest Standing American Whiskey brand in US History - Maintained Continuously Since 1810

Story american old overholt